The Three Types of Mechanical Switches
Now that you know what a mechanical switch is, it's time to explore the three fundamental categories that define their feel and sound. Every mechanical switch on the market falls into one of these three families: Linear, Tactile, or Clicky. The difference between them all comes down to the shape of the stem inside the switch, which dictates the sensory feedback you receive with each keystroke.
Choosing between these three types is the first and most important step in finding your perfect switch. It's all about personal preference, so there's no right or wrong answer. It's a journey to discover what feels best under your fingers.
Finding Your Feel: Linear, Tactile, or Clicky?
Now that you know what a mechanical switch is, it's time to explore the three fundamental categories that define their feel and sound. Every mechanical switch on the market falls into one of these three families: Linear, Tactile, or Clicky. The difference between them all comes down to the shape of the stem inside the switch, which dictates the sensory feedback you receive with each keystroke.
Choosing between these three types is the first and most important step in finding your perfect switch. It's all about personal preference, so there's no right or wrong answer. It’s a journey to discover what feels best under your fingers. Let's break them down.
1. Linear Switches: Smooth and Consistent
The Feel: Linear switches are the simplest of the three. They provide a smooth, consistent, and uninterrupted keystroke from the moment you start pressing the key until you bottom out. There is no bump or click in the middle. The resistance comes purely from the spring, so the force increases uniformly as you press down. Imagine pressing a button that glides effortlessly on a cushion of air.
-
Why Choose Linear?
- Speed and Gaming: The smooth, uninterrupted travel makes them a favorite for fast-paced gaming, where rapid, repeated keystrokes are common and any tactile "hitch" could be a distraction. The lack of a tactile event can make quick, successive presses feel more fluid.
- Quiet Operation: With no built-in bump or click, linear switches are generally the quietest of the three types. The only sound they produce comes from the keycap "bottoming out" (hitting the top of the switch housing) or "topping out" (returning to its resting position). This makes them a considerate choice for office or shared environments.
- Predictable Feel: The consistent force can be very comfortable for long typing sessions if you prefer a smooth, frictionless feel. They are often described as "cloud-like" when properly lubricated.
-
Classic Examples:
- Cherry MX Red: The archetypal light linear switch (45g). It set the standard for what a linear switch should be.
- Gateron Yellow: A community favorite, beloved for its exceptional smoothness and budget-friendly price. Often considered smoother than its Cherry counterpart out of the box.
- NovelKeys Cream: A premium linear switch known for its unique self-lubricating POM material, which leads to a distinct sound signature and feel.
- Gateron Ink Black: A high-end linear switch praised for its incredibly smooth travel and deep sound profile, thanks to its special housing material.
2. Tactile Switches: The Satisfying Bump
The Feel: Tactile switches are the happy medium for many users. As you press the key, you'll feel a noticeable "bump" partway through the travel. This bump provides clear feedback to your fingers, letting you know that the keystroke has been registered. This means you don't need to "bottom out" (press the key all the way down) to actuate the switch, which can encourage a lighter, more efficient typing style.
-
Why Choose Tactile?
- Typing Feedback: The bump is incredibly satisfying for many typists. It confirms that a key has been pressed, which can help improve accuracy and confidence without needing an audible cue.
- A Great All-Rounder: Tactile switches are often considered the best of both worlds, providing enough feedback for confident typing while remaining smooth enough for enjoyable gaming. They are the versatile workhorses of the switch world.
- Variety: The "tactile event" can vary wildly between switches, from a small, gentle bump to a large, sharp, and pronounced one. This creates a huge spectrum of options within the tactile category itself.
-
Classic Examples:
- Cherry MX Brown: The most well-known tactile switch. It has a relatively light tactile bump, making it a popular and safe choice for people new to mechanical keyboards. Some enthusiasts find the bump too subtle, describing it as a "scratchy linear."
- Holy Panda: A legendary "frankenswitch" (made from the parts of two different switches) famous for its sharp, "rounded" tactile bump right at the top of the keypress. It's a "no-compromise" tactile experience.
- Zealios V2: A premium tactile switch known for its very distinct, crisp, and "sharp" tactility. It's a great example of a modern tactile switch designed for enthusiasts.
- Boba U4T: A very popular modern tactile switch known for its deep "thocky" sound signature and a satisfying, rounded bump.
3. Clicky Switches: Loud and Proud
The Feel and Sound: Clicky switches are the most audacious of the bunch. They are just like tactile switches, but with an extra feature: in addition to the tactile bump, they also produce a sharp, audible "click" sound at the point of actuation. This sound is generated by a more complex mechanism inside the switch, such as a "click jacket" or a "click bar."
-
Why Choose Clicky?
- Unmistakable Feedback: The combination of the tactile bump and the audible click provides the strongest possible feedback that a key has been pressed. Many people find this incredibly satisfying and reminiscent of old-school IBM Model M keyboards or classic typewriters.
- For the Love of Sound: If you love the sound of a clicky keyboard and work in an environment where it won't bother anyone (like a home office), these can be an absolute joy to use.
-
The Downsides: They are loud. Very loud. This makes them unsuitable for most office environments, classrooms, or any shared living spaces. Use them with consideration for those around you!
-
Classic Examples:
- Cherry MX Blue: The quintessential clicky switch, famous for its distinct click and tactile bump. It uses a "click jacket" design that can feel less crisp than more modern designs.
- Kailh BOX White: A popular clicky switch that uses a "click bar" mechanism. This design separates the tactile event from the click generation, resulting in a crisper, cleaner click that happens at the same time as actuation. Many enthusiasts prefer this design.
- Kailh BOX Jade: A heavier version of the BOX White with a much thicker click bar, resulting in a deeper, more aggressive, and extremely satisfying click.
Your choice between Linear, Tactile, and Clicky will have the biggest impact on your day-to-day typing experience. The best way to find out what you like is to try them out with a switch tester, but this guide should give you a great starting point for your exploration.
Next, we'll go a level deeper and look at the specific characteristics that define a switch beyond these three categories. Let's explore Understanding Switch Characteristics.